I had to give the Rathskeller five stars - I have so many good memories of this place. As a student, you come here to get away from our housemates, on break from class, to study, to watch open mike night, to grab some Bascom ice cream, and the list goes on. Only in Wisconsin is the student union heavily influenced by German food, libations, and decor.
This won't be the fanciest place you've been but it shouldn't be. It's an every man's place and everyone feels home here. On Wisconsin.