The short version: the burgers were barely average but the sides and service were great.
The positive of this place really focuses on the customer service and the amazing sides. We started with the Gouda cheese sticks, I know other reviews didn't find them amazing but we did. The melty goodness had a great batter and the ranch/BBQ dip was really a good pairing. With the burger we got the Mac and cheese, which seemed to have an extra something savory in it, and the bread pudding which was sweet but not too sweet. If I had to stop there this place would be a five but I must continue...
The burger... the name sake of this joint was blah. The bun was dry and stayed dry since he meat was also dry. No grill flavor or juices with this burger so don't look for it. The sell was that it was a garlic burger, a Halloween these to keep the vampires away. I'm pretty sure even vampires wouldn't have noticed the garlic flavor either. The burger was just so dang boring it can't be what they are supposed to be good at.
Try again Crafty Burger...