We were heading to a show at Massey Hall and wanted to have a nice dinner in the area. So we picked Portico after reading the Yelp reviews. I have to say our dining experience did not reflect most reviews. Our waiter was very, very nice- but likely had just started. He did not see to know much about the menu items, made a mistake on our order, and mixed up our plates when they finally came to the table. But he did a great job at making us feel welcome and keeping our drinks coming.
For the food I am definitely on the "Meh. I've experienced better"- particularly for a $100 meal for two! Bread was brought out when we arrived, but was on the stale side. Starter was nice- no complaints there. Mains ordered were both steaks. Good, but not worth the price paid. Cooked well (at least they were once we switched plates- medium well for a medium rare!), but a bit tough. Potatoes were fine, green beans were beans, and the tomatoe was a tomatoe. All in all an okay meal, but not worth going back again.