I decided to try lamb for the first time and thankfully I tried it at Baxter's when they weren't busy. That was among the most tender and flavorful meals I've ever eaten and the sides were just as expertly crafted as the main course.
I've been here twice. once they were jam packed because of a concert that was down the street, the other we were one of two parties to arrive early in the evening. I would avoid trying to steal a seat when they are jam packed, the speed and quality of service suffers a bit, and you don't want to miss out on the best this place can offer you.
I would highly recommend anyone to make a reservation early in the evening and try the Herb Crusted lamb chops with your preferred appetizer and side, you won't regret it.