Disappointing is how I would start this review. We love the place and have been going here for years but the food here is just not as good as it once was. The bar was fun, we had an excellent waitress but once we sat down to eat it just wasn't up to fish fry good. My broiled cod was cooked right but was tasteless. It sat all alone on a big hot plate with nothing else to make it stand out. The hash browns we got family style, a big plate in the middle, were terrible. None of us would eat them. They had an "off" taste that was sort of moldy tasting.Our waitress immediately replaced them with baked potatoes which were perfect. My partner had fried cod which again was cooked perfectly but just sort of thrown on a plate. The baby pike which is Walleye was another choice was reported as a little overcooked and dry. We know that Fridays here are overcrowded and looked forward to coming on a Thursday for a good fish fry and it just didn't meet the mark. There is not many places left around Madison that still have a consistently good Wisconsin fish fry and Toby's needs to raise the bar and put a little more care in what they are doing.