AVOID! AVOID! AVOID! Where do I start? Yes, I read the Yelp reviews. Yes, they were bad. So bad that a sane person would have avoided this poor excuse for a seafood restaurant (but I went anyway...MISTAKE).
Most of the poor reviews were due to sub-standard service. My experience? The service was HORRIFICALLY bad. Waited unreasonably long for drink order to be taken. Waited unreasonably long for drinks to arrive. Was able to sneak in an appetizer order for calamari when drinks finally arrived. Waited unreasonably long for calamari to arrive. Surprised? Calamari was fair at best. When the appetizer arrive I finally placed the dinner order. I ordered the prime rib...rare. My dinner guest ordered some type of fish. Guess what took unreasonably long? Yes, the dinner orders. As a matter of fact, after waiting unreasonably long for dinner to arrive, someone came to the table to let me know they ran out of rare cuts of prime rib, but they could do medium rare. So I said that would be fine. What they brought literally looked like over-cooked pot roast. It was beyond well-done...it was dry. The fish that my guest ordered was tough and fishy (smelling and tasting).
This place has become a joke. Do yourself a favor and AVOID the disappointment. If you're up for seafood stick to the Mastro's restaurants. They've got a recipe for success and always please.