Not sure of the negative reviews, but I think the sandwiches are decent on its own and this is a popular local joint in the area.
Really good solid Italian sandwiches that are HUGE to eat. For less than $8 a bun, you will definitely be stuffed. Veal sandwich seems to be the most popular choice as it is quite tasty, I got the meatball which is also very good as well.
Bread is soft and moist with a 80% meat and 20% bun ratio. The meat and sauce tastes homemade and good to eat when you want something else other than a burger. Not the cheapest thing for just meat-on-a-bun but you can add onions and jalapeno peppers for free. Beware - the jalapenos are spicy like death and required several cups of milk.
Worth a try!