If I came to Cowboy Ciao for only the Stetson Salad, I would give them 5-Stars. That salad is extremely delicious, all of the ingredients melt into your mouth and create a delicious flavor. I also enjoyed the atmosphere of this restaurant, great date place in Old Town.
On the other hand, my mother and I also ordered a Mini mushroom dish with a short ribs entree. The mini mushroom had a great sauce but the polenta was too heavy for the dish. Highly anticipating the short ribs smoked pastrami style was not what we expected at all. Meat was dry and over-seasoned. Needed to ask our waitress for additional sauce - mashed potatoes and brusselsprouts were the best part of the meal.
Service was better than average, our waitress knew the menu like the back of her hand. Very seasoned just wish our dishes were better.