Four Words: Birthday Cake Ice Cream
Honestly, when I was living in Pittsburgh I'd have to make the trek down to Oakland just for this ice cream every once in awhile. It is so creamy and fattening its really amazing. Nothing comes close in Pittsburgh.
The aforementioned birthday cake ice cream truly tastes like your eating a cake and I would recommended it to any first timers for a culinary experience like none other.
I'm going to be in Pittsburgh in a couple months and for sure I'll be stopping at Dave & Andy's asap.