I was surprised by the other reviews. I think they've upped their game since then: my wife and I go to this pub fairly regularly and always enjoy our time.
I have discovered their soups are excellent, and always order a bowl of their soup to go along with a sandwich or burger. The food has always been top-notch. The ambiance is warm and friendly, and the servers always polite and helpful.
There are enough TVs around, so if you want to catch whatever game is on, you've got lots of opportunity.
I recommend the place if you find yourself hungry and thirsty in Tuscany. Try their soup!