I've been to the Pizza Brutta on Monroe St many times and have always enjoyed so when I heard there would be a new one in Middleton, we were very excited. However, our first visit was a disappointment.
Food - The pizza just didn't seen as good here as on Monroe St. It was very soggy in the middle and all the topping fell off, don't remember that before. The amount of mozzarella cheese was skimpy on the Margherita and we also ordered a pizza with the special buffalo cheese and it covered only about 10% of the pizza. The sausage was very tasty and the tomato sauce was good too.
Price - you know going in to visiting Pizza Brutta that you are paying a premium for the food. Based on what we ate on this visit we felt like we were overcharged and would have been better off getting a Costco cheese pizza and adding our own fresh toppings like we do from time to time.
Atmosphere - they have done a nice job with the layout of the new restaurant. The oven is very much front and center for everyone to see and the booth were comfortable.
I have heard from others mixed reviews, perhaps we will give it another try in a few months when we feel like overspending on pizza.