Pizza by the slice...I thought I left that back in NY. I was very happy to find a place that does slices. Jimmy and Joe's just does not do slices they do SLICES. However, do not get too excited this is not NY pizza. Very far from it. The crust is super doughy and the cheese and sauce are just OK. This slice would never make it back home. It would be sent to Pizza jail for perpetrating a REAL slice. Hey but what do I expect this is AZ.
I have been here numerous times and we order regularly from them for delivery. It is kind of hit and miss with the slices when you go in. I am guessing because they are usually sitting there and you have to reheat them etc. When we order delivery the pies are great, hot, cheesy with fresh toppings. So I would say if you are in their range for delivery then by all means do so or pick up a pie. They can keep the slices. The salads are OK. I think they should invest in better dressing. They use the cheap store brought stuff and you can definitely tell. J and J upgrade to better dressing.
The place seems to be run my a bunch of teenagers. I never see anyone in there older than 22 or so. But I have to say they are always attentive, cheerful and get your food out to you ASAP. However, if you are staying in to eat be prepared for teenage chatter as the staffers have friends coming and going. Can get a bit annoying but that could just be me.