I am giving Courthouse Pizza three stars but they should get 3 1/2 - they are not 4...yet!
I have read the older reviews and some of the complaints have been changed/fixed. They now have metal silverware, the pizzas are 18" now (not 16") and they will give you a New York slice (you need to fold it) or they will cut it in half so you can hold it....ummmm...Ohio style? The restaurant is clean and is has a well designed interior.
I do wish they had better quality napkins and tables/chairs with more style.
It is a thin crust pizza and if you don't like that you won't like their pizza. I like thick, thin, Chicago, hot, cold, round, square...wait sorry got lost dreaming of pizza...well any type of pizza.
As you can see in the pictures they give a generous amount of toppings and the staff was friendly.
It is hard to find a good local, eat-in pizza place (sorry no yellow/orange plastic franchise McPizza for me - I hope McBurger doesn't try pizza next). I will be back and I hope Courthouse continues to improve...give them a try when in Medina.