I went to the Watershed last Thursday and I loved it. So I came back on Monday afternoon and the Watershed was closed. So we came to Pier 54 instead.
The food and drinks are much more casual compared to the Watershed. I had soup and salad and my friend had a burger. We enjoyed our food and the service was great.
The view of the lake is not as good as The Watershed.
Overall, it was a good experience, but I don't see any reason why I would come back.