More like 3.5 stars. Barb's is a true bakery. You walk in and you feel like you are in a small town shop that's excited to bake a cake for your occasion. Everyone is so friendly. We just wanted a a little something sweet to nosh on so we grabbed some cookies and cupcakes. Overall, everything was good. Not out of this world, but it was good. The german chocolate and lemon raspberry were my favorite cupcakes. I bet that lemon/raspberry flavor would be great in a sheet cake.