I was really disappointed when Dozen closed up shop in Squirrel Hill so I was thrilled to discover this place today. I got a pumpkin spice cupcake. The cupcake itself was dense, but moist. The icing was light and fluffy, but a tad sweet than I prefer. I will definitely go back and try some other flavors.
On the Pittsburgh cupcake scale, I'd say they were better than Dozen, but not as good as Vanilla Pastry Studio. I've never tried the other place in Shadyside.