For a summer out door siting experience I give it 5 stars. But the food is ok for the price, but if you're bringing NYC pizza prices to WI you better bring some serious pizza. The one we had was ok, not terrible but not brilliant. I'm sure the ingredients are fine but it just didn't blow our socks off. I thought these were going to be a bit thinner crust as they are billed as "euro" style pizza's. They are a cross between New York style and something with fun toppings.
If I want a thin crust pizza in the future and don't really care about sitting outside I'll look at Pizza Bruta first.
We also had the Caprese Salad which was ok. To make a really good caprese salad you need three things. A really fresh tomato, really fresh mozzarella and basil. The tomato was clearly not fresh (probably from CA or Mexico) and it affected the taste.
The gelato we had was pretty good and we will probably come back to get gelato and walk around Middleton or sit outside and people watch.
Overall I wanted to love this place more than I did. Pizza just ok, caprese was not with a ripe tomato (its late June, there are fresh and ripe tomatoes to be had) and the gelato was pretty good. Loved the outdoor seating, waitress was just ok. We will be back, but we're not running back.