I went here recently with a large group of people. We were seated as quickly as possible and ordered different things.
Everyone insisted that the pizza was the best in CLE, but my wife and I didn't see it. We split a pepperoni and, while we enjoyed the thickness of the pepperoni, we found the pizza sauce to be underwhelming and the grease to be excessive. Pizza is known to be greasy, but it seemed to roll out of the pizza in waves and almost took the cheese with it.
My wife was also not a fan of the calamari pasta - now, she loves calamari in all its incarnations and especially in pasta. However, she was very put out by how chewy the calamari in the pasta was - calamari in pasta is normally fried to be crispy but not the calamari here. It created a weird texture in the pasta for her that made the pasta difficult to find appetizing. She also found the pasta sauce to be simple and - I quote - "out of a can".
Is the pizza and pasta decent? Yes. Is it tasty? Yes. Is it the best in CLE? No, at least not from what we experienced. We will definitely go again when we want pizza at a fair price rather quickly, but from now on will keep our expectations limited to good pizza at a good price.