Can't go wrong with Scaddabush. It was a random place I decided to try out and now it's a fav spot for my girl friend and I. I even had my birthday there in December. My booking was messed up a little but it didn't bother me as their food and drinks are always on point.
Our go to is their mozzarella platters with a pitcher of sangria. Mmmm!
If you haven't, try this place out. There's also one next to Sq one and both locations are convenient for both my girl friend and I.