I wanted to LOVE this place, but I ended up just liking it. I'm giving four stars because I don't want to hurt the current rating and I think there's lots of hope for this resto to really pull it out of the water and deserve a solid four stars.
My friend and I were there on Tuesday night this week and sat at the bar. I'm really glad we did because the service we received was really good. When we ordered, we mentioned we were sharing and our server cleverly put our order - 3 entrees - on one lovely platter. This is the way to eat at Zocalo! You can order things on their own and you may not want to make a whole meal out of it - like the lovely cottage cheese cake or the terrine of mushrooms. The asparagus is delicious and so was the sausage. However, if it all comes together and you get a bite of this and that, it makes a much more interesting meal. Pair with some good beer (Beau's Lug Tread at a mere $5.75/pint) and you're gold. The price points of the entrees ($10-$13) make it worthwhile ordering more for variety's sake.
The decor is nice and comfy - hip without a lot of junk 'objets' laying about. Bathrooms are very nice and clean. The crowd was pretty mixed up - all types of folks all having a good time. Love that they accept Amex. Also love that they have a back patio - too cold when we were there, but it looks nice.
There were a few issues with the service, but it wasn't our server - just another one with a bad attitude who was a bit distracting.
Anyways, I'll definitely be back as it's a nice find in our neighbourhood. I'm sure they'll work out the shortcomings service-wise. Fingers crossed, Zocalo!