Amazing ribs and sauce. The chicken is pretty good, too.
Problems are:
-Small, relatively unimpressive sides (those mashed potatoes are definitely instant).
-They charge you for sharing! Even when my boyfriend and I were ordering take-out a la carte ribs on the phone, they asked him if he would be sharing with anyone so they could tack-on that extra $1.50! What's up with that?
-The dine-in experience (like many have already posted) isn't great, since it's so small and there's no beer.
All that said, Smoky Jon's has the best ribs in town. Trust me, I've tried every rib spot in Madison.