I like to stop by Dave & Andy's every once awhile to give them another shot but I've just never been super overwhelmed by their flavors. I always expect them to be delicious and interesting (because the flavor sounds delicious and interesting) but usually feel let down. That being said, I tried the pumpkin cookies 'n' cream and the chocolate chip cookie dough when I was last there and they were pretty good. The shop is small and cash only, but it's a pretty good deal (only an extra quarter or so to get a second flavor). All things considered I'd give them a solid 3.5 stars.