Every time I step into Jimmy O'Neill's I think "Now THIS is a tavern." I feel like I've walked onto a set built for some period piece about sailors about to travel across the pond. The dining area is moody and twinkle light filled and most anyone would describe ti as cute. I love the atmosphere of the tavern, and if you're an Amy follower you'll know that's what I put before almost anything else (exception being cleanliness). I'd love to give the tavern 5 stars just for creating a romantic experience. However, I need to be realistic. You come to a tavern to eat and drink. In the food and bev department, my experience has been about average. Nothing really looks that great on the menu and from what I've tasted, it isn't. I think you can have a really great time at Jimmy O'Neill's Tavern, just set your expectations accordingly. The draw is the mood, not the food.