We went here on a Wednesday afternoon for a quick lunch and glass of wine and were very happy with the experience.
We shared a bruschetta board which was very good. I was a big fan of the bread as I miss our bakeries back east. The wine selection is good enough without being overwhelming. The selections aren't the every day generic choices you get in a lot of places also.
Only downside is we sat outside in the sun and it was a bit warmer than we anticipated, but this was our own fault. The hostess asked if we wanted another seat as it might be a bit sunny.
I can see how if this were a Friday night how the place could be overwhelmingly crowded and noisy as others have pointed out. So I would shy away from hitting the place up at peak times. It was fairly crowded for an early Wednesday afternoon.
So why 4 of 5? I will and want to go back, but can wait on it. I thought the menu was a bit limited, so not much else was screaming to me "Come back ASAP!". The appetizers I remember being on the pricey side as well.