I will gladly drive 40 miles from my house to Casella's for their food.
They have become my top stop Italian deli.
Recently, I tried their Italian and cheesesteak sandwiches. Both were awesome.
I also love their salads. I had the pasta and chicken salad. The chicken salad receives my only small complaint, because it is a little too thick for my taste.
Maybe they need to ease up on the mayonnaise or something. I don't know.
This place gets extremely busy around lunch time, but the service is quick. Try to remember that they do not take debit / credit cards or checks. Cash is king.
The Casella family is like a well-oiled machine: dad runs around, making sure everything is orderly and clean, while mom and the daughters handle cooking, food prep, and the front counter.
I simply love this place....even more than DeFalco's.