I've been to Eleven numerous times, and not once have I been even remotely disappointed. Most recently, a friend and I stopped in for happy hour after work and enjoyed some Eleven Mules and oysters on the half shell. I had the salmon special and the roasted cauliflower was AMAZING (especially for cauliflower, of all things). My friend got the Eleven Burger with goat cheese as usual; she can't get past that on the menu because it's so good.
If you're looking for a nice place where you can be sure the dinner will stand out, Eleven is the place to go.