Rusty bucket is your typical American, pub-type fare with an atmosphere that matches. Prices might be a tad higher than usual for things like a burger or chicken sandwich (maybe $1 above), but it's always good food. Drink prices are average and fair with some notable specials throughout the week. Can't go wrong with a burger or any of the sandwiches really.
I almost hate letting the secret out, but this is my new go-to brunch spot if other places like Tupelo or Toast are too crowded. Surprisingly, Rusty Bucket has a good brunch menu. Try the short rib hash, it's really good. Chicken and waffles are really tasty as well. There's not a huge selection, but the dishes available are done well. REALLY wish they had a better mimosa deal during the weekend for brunch.
I was on the fence about 3 or 4 stars, but the service is ALWAYS exceptional and friendly, so taking that into consideration pushes it up to 4 stars for me.