I heard good things about this place from a co-worker and decided to give it a try. I ordered the chicken w/two sides.
First the sides. I ordered mashed potatos and gravy. Overall not really that impressed. It was a little on the bland side. The gravy just needed a bit more flavor and tilt would have been fine.
The mac and cheese was different then I'm normally used to getting in a reaturant. I was pretty happy with the flavor and was surprised to see it was cheesy.
The portion size for both was fine. It was enough to fill you up. I can see some people having an issue but since this was lunch i didn't want a huge pile of sides and suffer later at work.
The chicken. The meal came with a drumstick and thigh. The skin was nice and chrsipy and had great flavor. In reading the other reviews from other people I can see why they may not think it's the best. While the flavor was good it didn't do anything to make it stand out against the others so I can see why people wither thought it was the best or worst.
Overall the place looked clean on the inside and the staff was friendly.
Ibby's has a great experience overall.