I would give it 3.5 to 4 star. Tried three different cakes from here (not on same day if course lol) and all are above average. They have a great selection of very pretty looking cakes. Tried their double or triple layered chocolate fudge cake, vanilla cake and today bought their pink velvet. My favorite is actually the pink velvet. Very soft and moist on the inside and the cream cheese icing is very yummy.