Food was mediocre at best. My husband and I both had the Create Your Own Calzones and I had a side Cesar Salad added on. The Cesar dressing was clearly from a bottle with nothing special about it. They mixed up the toppings inside our calzones so that my husband ended up with pepperoni which he did not order, and mine had black olives which I didn't order. I also didn't think I had the pepperoni in mine until I found it in the last third of the calzone all bunched together, instead of spread evenly throughout. We also felt there wasn't enough sauce provided on the side to last through the entire calzone. Service was decent, but overall the experience was mediocre at best. Don't think we'll be back to Old Chicago.