I don't know if anybody has a big enough sweet tooth as I do, but I thoroughly enjoyed Red Bench. From what I've remember, I've been here 3 times and I intend on coming back for more. Red bench serves frozen yogurt and made to order cookies.
Although the yogurt and toppings choices are minimal ( compared to Yogurts and Menchies), I think the decor and the presentation of this place gives this place 5 stars.
P.S. Stock up on the brownie and cheesecake pieces on the bottom before putting in frozen yogurt, you can fit a lot more in a cup this way. Trust me.