3.5 stars would be more accurate for my experience.
My business partner and I had a late dinner and a beer here last night. There beer selection is second to none (or at least second to very few). There are not many places that you are going to be able to find Dogfish Head 90 IPA on tap. My 90 minute was great, good head on the beer. No issues at all there.
I had the pastrami sandwich and french onion soup. I am a bit of a fanatic about french onion soup. I would give their an average to a little above average rating. The broth/base of the soup was not all the thick but the crouton, onion and cheese were all done well to make up for some what the broth/base was lacking. My sandwich was good but really nothing more than average. The pickled jalapenos did give the sandwich a nice kick though.
I had only had only been to Yard House once before for lunch and would go back more often if I still lived in the area.
All in all I think Yard House stands out a great spot to get some beers/drinks but the food is a little above average. I guess that is about what is to be expected when the draw is the massive beer selection. I would definitely eat there again, just don't see me making a point of it.