For years I've been searching for a place like Ciao Roma! Hands down the best pizza I've had in Toronto and you get to have as many varieties as you want/can stuff in your face. This isn't your average round pizza - they are large rectangular pies that they slice and warm for you.
We originally ordered small(ish) slices of 4 different varieties, but they brought out a fresh pie while we were scarfing down Round One and HAD to get it (I forget what it was, but balsamic glaze was involved and it was amazing!). And why not?! Less than $20 with sodas and we left completely stuffed. I can't make any particular recommendations because they were all amaze-balls!
Cash only, so keep that in mind before you go! AND YOU MUST GO! Do it!