Several minutes after leaving WatchFinder in Yorkville with a beautiful and extremely reasonably priced antique Piaget, my wife turned to me and said: "that was the best luxury purchase from a watch or jewelry I've ever had"--high praise from someone who, years ago, worked in New York City's jewelry industry.
I tend to agree with her. Watch Finder staff were extremely knowledgeable, willing to accommodate our budget and generally pleasant to interact with.
You know when you meet someone and they just have a deep and genuine interest for their subject matter area? That's how these guys are with watches.
We'll definitely be coming back whenever we have the need to buy a high-end watch. If any of my friends were to ask me if I know a place in Toronto where they could get a quality watch, I wouldn't even mention anything else. Just Watch Finder in Yorkville.