I've been coming to this Hawthorne's location pretty much since they opened, and I don't think they've ever screwed up an order.
Pizza is delicious and if you haven't tried the Buffalo Wing Pizza, give it a whirl. Meatballs for the calzones, or for a side dish, or even for a sandwich are also spot on.
They almost always have a new beer special on tap, so be sure to ask your waiter about that as well.
Definitely recommended, might be the best pizza in the queen city.