I used to think that this place was amazing before having been to any other all you can eat sushi restaurant... Makimono pales in comparison.
The rolls are mediocre, selection for vegetarians is OK, and I once found a hair on my gyoza. Service is OK also, however our server once made us redo our order form because we "marked our orders down wrong" when she never actually told us how to "mark them down correctly", and was even then reluctant to give us a new paper to redo it on.
In terms of the take-out menu, it's quite expensive for not-so-high quality items.
The one thing I like about this place over other all you can eat sushi restaurants is the atmosphere; the place is big and there's some nice booths and rooms that you can sit at.
Overall, while many people in Pickering love Makimono (as they have never had an alternative), I would suggest checking out some other all you can eat sushi places nearby. Sushi T&T in Ajax is wonderful and not much further (and I believe less expensive)!