Bar Room can be great, or it can be a complete miss. To be honest with you I haven't been there on a Friday in over atleast 6 months, because the summer time was all about West Sixth bar hopping.. but now that it's cold Bar Room is where it's at.
The best thing about this club is the HUGE dance floor. You can find a spot to dance without too much of an annoyance, and they have ample seating if you wanna take a break, unlike at any of the West Sixth bars.
VIP can be very fun at Bar Room, the girls are great in this area, seating is pretty comfortable and prices are reasonable considering... Do it once and they welcome you back with special prices and actually remember who you are.