Bad surprise. People of Montreal, how can you find this place to incredible? I agree, the owner is super nice, and the pie concept is fun. But it is not super tasty, and it's quite expensive for what it is (just a few ingredients in a dough, basically). The sides were also so-so (we had mac & cheese and mashed potatoes). And finally, the shop itself is not really nice to eat in - I guess it's better to take away and go eat in the nearby park.
A bit disappointed, even if Hugh Jackman seems to disagree :)