I've gone here countless times, and I've ordered the same thing every time (except once when I had pizza)....so this review is kind of stupid, but all I know is that I always walk away mega-full and very happy about it.
The only thing that bothers me is when I'm stuck at one of the tables crammed between other tables, and they are VERY close together so it's hard to not overhear or be overheard (I wouldn't recommend this place for a super-romantic/whispering in your honey bun's ear type of night).
The servers have always been super nice, and patient with my bf and his beer-choosing dilemmas. Waiting in a lineup in the cold sucks since this place doesn't take resos (dunno if that's changed in recent times), but the lineup USUALLY goes quite quickly.
I dig the patio out back, it's cool.
I'd go here more often than I already have if I didn't live right near Terroni Bar Centrale.