I'm so down for the explosion of poke places in Madison, Wisconsin. I was in Hawaii last summer and literally still dream about the abundance of fresh, buttery, flavorful poke that you could find there pretty much any place you went. I've not yet made it out to other poke places in Madison but if they're anything like Poke Plus, I'd say Madison is in pretty good poke hands.
This location replaces the old Disco Fries restaurant, which I never entered but walked by every day and was not surprised to see go under because I hardly ever saw anyone in there. I think the location works much better as a poke place - it's a quick light lunch you can grab to go and the service is quick and efficient. The fish is fresh and the sauces are yummy - probably the only qualm is portions are a bit small for what you pay but it is poke so I'm happy to pay it. I also got their salmon teriyaki too go one day and it was very satisfying - a surprising amount of fish and very flavorful. Definitely will add Poke Plus into my rotation of "i'm on campus and want to have lunch but don't want to eat at the Union" places.