One of the best places to come in Madison when you're looking for your typical American food, or if you want a Mediterranean twist on that same food. They've got everything from burgers to salads to falafel, and I find myself staring at the menu for ages every time I visit. This is an especially good place to bring a quarreling group because you're sure to find something for everyone, including vegetarians. The burgers are pretty solid - I especially recommend their patty melts. Be sure to order the waffle fries to complement your food - they're fried to a perfect crisp that makes them fluffy and crunchy at the same time.
While Amy's makes for a great restaurant experience, it totally falls flat as a bar experience. The drink specials are lousy 90% of the time, and the interior setup is not at all conducive to a bar crowd. I avoid getting drinks here because they're always expensive and the bartenders are pretty surly. And it's tiny in there; I have enough trouble fitting in Amy's without a line out the door.