Somewhat disappointing based on the other reviews. My sandwich and side salad were fine. That's it. I had The Madison (I think that's what it was called, its no longer listed on their website). Hummus, feta, veggies on so-so bread (from a local bakery--I'd switch bakeries if it were up to me). I would chosen something else if the menu had specified that it was not plain hummus. Seemed to be red pepper hummus, which I typically don't care for. And it didn't work because they paired flavored hummus with flavored feta. It would make more sense to only have one or the other (if any) flavored. The salad was ok, could have been more special. People are trying to make this place out to be something more than what it is: a place with food in a strip mall in Monona.