I'm changing my rating to 5 stars!
I've now visited The Old Fashioned a handful of times, and I love the place. The Old Fashioned has also found itself a spot on my personal "must eat" list for out-of-towners. My husband and I have taken his sister, some of my cousins, and my parents to The Old Fashioned when they've been in Madison visiting. We think it showcases Wisconsin food wonderfully, and we like taking non-Wisconsinites there to eat.
We've tried several different dishes and have enjoyed them all. I'm not even much of a beef eater, but the Wisconsin Burger is really to die for. (The egg on top? Yummy!!!)
Side note: stop by The Old Fashioned booth at the Taste of Madison to grab a handful of cheese curds! :-) I do this every year.