I went to Ultra Collision to get a repair done on the rubber rear bumper on my Acura TL; someone had backed into it right behind the rear tire and taken a gash out of it and broke off the clips holding it on. I explained to the owner Steve that this was going to be below my insurance deductible and so I was going to have to pay out of pocket, and he made me a great deal AND also fixed two scuffs on the corners of my front air dam (I did those), explaining that he would already have the paint so it was no big deal. It all looks like new again! He did great work, got it done in two days and even gave me a ride home when I dropped it off (I live just a couple miles from the shop).
I'll admit I was heartened when I walked into his office and it was FILLED with Boston Red Sox memorabilia (he and his wife are from Rhode Island, I found out), since I am from Vermont myself. Still, I think he would do a great job even for a Yankees fan :)