I am not a real cupcake connoisseur but I do like a moist cupcake with a decent amount of icing that is sweet but not too sweet, and with flavour if it is meant to have flavour.
I had the Vanilla Fig and it was super yummy. $1.50 for a bite? At least I don't have to eat a whole cupcake, I can just select a few mini ones and eat a whole bunch.
I have also visited Dlish on Yonge street (By Yonge / Bloor) and it was heavenly there as well.