I went here last night (Wednesday, 27 September 2017) to grab 2 slices of Pepperoni pizza. I randomly walked in here after attending a Yelp event at the Cleveland Candle Company. I was really hungry and I just wanted something to eat fast.
I give this place a 3.0 rating. The pizza here was good and basic. Nothing fancy. I mean, I was really hungry so maybe my food tasting judgment was clowded but I'm not sure why all the reviews are so bad. I mean, it's just PIZZA y'all. I will definitely say that I've tasted better pizza. I lived in Chicago for 3.5 years so trust me, I know good pizza and I'm not just talking about deep dish pizza.
The crust on Guy's pizza didn't seemed fully cooked at all parts and the red sauce was lacking. I would say that if you're running late and need something to eat real quick then grab a slice here but if you want to sit down with some friends for dinner then go somewhere else. The inside of this place looked old and I read in one review that there are no indoor bathrooms (say whaaat?!?!). Oh well, this pizza joint seems to be a 'order out and go' rather than a sit-in place.