It so happens that my male friends frequently ask me where to take a girl they like on a first date, and even though I like to try new things and branch out and be original, I always say: Take her to Pullman. And they always get laid.
Kidding! I actually haven't been able to keep track of how successful they've been. That's how often I recommend Pullman!
I think every server must be a sommelier because they are so knowledgeable about the wine, and they never try to trick you into getting something just because it's more expensive. In fact, they make you feel like it's really normal to be mildly concerned about the price by casually asking you for a range when suggesting a bottle.
The food is great, and I don't know why I love ticking my order off a paper menu with a pencil so much, but maybe it's because it feels like a little personality quiz. It's interactive, and with one menu and one pencil, you know you're sharing the food with your date. They always have oysters and there is a flight of sparkling wines on the menu, so aphrodisiac central for those of you looking to seal the deal.
Maybe it's more of a third date place. I don't know. I won't judge you either way.