If I was only rating based on the filet I ordered this would be a 4++; so tender, so perfectly cooked; so yummy. Unfortunately my husband also ordered the cedar plank salmon which drew down the rating considerably; the presentation on the creamed spinach was a miss...the same very bitter creamed spinach that was served with my dish...it was inedible. And the mashed potatoes were fine but just sort of uninspiring....the best you can do for a starch side dish is mashed potatoes with some butter? I do like that they still serve bread with dinner. The apple crumble was nice to finish with. Re value....it's a mid range restaurant ambience wise, but price wise it's beyond the mid range experience. It would be a good choice for happy hour however.