I try to practice the "if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all" dealio, so I will give this place three stars.
Their candy selection is minimal (at best) in comparison to other candy stores in the valley. Their novelty section isn't that big either. They have some cute gifts and some candy that you don't see everywhere (tropical flavored Puntinis), but for what a small, niche shop this is - and the fact that it really can't get ANY foot traffic, I was surprised at how busy it was.
Based on some other reviews I had read it seemed that DH and I would be able to spend some time in the area, walking and shopping. Stinkweeds, a hair salon, and one other store are Smeeks' only neighbors. Not exactly my idea of a happenin' place to kill time.
Overall it was worth the one time trip. Probably more for tourists than die-hard candy snobs like my hubby.