Did not know what to expect upon deciding to come to Paul's. Well, this place made me a believer. Apparently this place has legendary status among the late night crowd in Madison, and I can see why.
Stopped in on a Friday afternoon after having a few beers at State Street Brats. I actually was dead set on going to Dotty Dumpling's Dowry, which is bad ass, for a burger but my friend convinced me to come here. I order a half serving of the mixed, potato and beef, with "the works". After one bite, I was convinced. The chili sauce with sour cream put these little suckers over the top as far as flavor goes and I instantly regretted not getting a full order. Next time...hell, maybe two full orders.
Service was polite. Diners order and receive their dishes at the same counter, as well as busing your own dishes, which to me is not a big deal. I especially liked that the cook preps your order in sight.
Great find in Madison.